• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Best Cookie Recipes
  • Cookie Recipes
  • Baking Tips
  • Classic Cookies
  • Meet Rebecca
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Cookie Recipes
  • Baking Tips
  • Classic Cookies
  • Meet Rebecca
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • Cookie Recipes
    • Baking Tips
    • Classic Cookies
    • Meet Rebecca
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube
  • ×
    Home / Drop Cookie

    Spiced Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies Recipe with Creamy Frosting

    Published on December 14, 2022 by Rebecca Johnston | Leave a Comment

    Share
    Pin
    Post
    Share
    Jump to Recipe

    Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies will bring you so much festive cheer! Made with warmly spiced eggnog, every bite is delicious—you won't be able to stop at just one!

    Top view of an eggnog pie sugar cookie on a plate next to a glass of molk and other eggnog pie cookies.

    Eggnog Sugar Cookie Pies are made with melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookies with a delicious eggnog filling on top.

    In fact, this recipe is inspired by the trending No Bake Eggnog Pie from Devour Dinner. These adorable mini eggnog pies are perfect for the holiday season as a cookie.

    If you like these mini eggnog cream pie cookies, you'll also love these Mini Pumpkin Pie Sugar Cookies that went bananas during the Thanksgiving Holiday.

    Both these cookie recipes are perfect for this time of year.

    I'm obsessed with all things eggnog - it's become one of my favorite holiday flavors! For all of you eggnog lovers out there, I see you!

    You don't actually need to be a massive eggnog fan to appreciate how cute and delicious these cookies are. You can make the eggnog flavor a bit milder by simply adding less eggnog, or you can make it more intense by adding more eggnog!

    For more eggnog inspiration, check out my Soft Eggnog Sugar Cookies with Eggnog Buttercream, these Eggnog Bars, or my delicious Eggnog Snickerdoodle Cookies with a rum glaze.

    Close up of eggnog pie cookies on a white plate.

    Shopping List

    Wet Ingredients. Butter, Vanilla Extract, Egg, Vegetable Oil, Eggnog,

    Dry Ingredients. All Purpose Flour, Granulated Sugar, Powdered Sugar, Baking Soda, Cream of Tartar, Vanilla Pudding, Salt

    Topping. Cool Whip, Ground Nutmeg

    How to Make Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies

    Sugar Cookies

    Firstly, preheat your oven to 350 F Degrees and make sure your ingredients for the cookies are all at room temperature before baking.

    In a large mixing bowl using an electric mixer, or using the large bowl of a stand mixer on medium speed, cream together softened Butter and Granulated Sugar until light and fluffy.

    Add the Egg and Vanilla Extract to the butter mixture and continue to mix together until fully combined.

    Drizzle the Vegetable Oil into the butter mixture then add the Powdered Sugar. Be sure to scrape the sides of the bowl as needed to include all ingredients. Cream until fully combined and fluffy.

    Combine the All-Purpose Flour, Baking Soda, and Cream of Tarter. Gradually combine the flour mixture with the butter mixture but do not overmix.

    Now you have your cookie sough, you need to make the cookies!

    Using a Medium #50 Cookie Scoop place one scoop of the sugar cookie dough in each muffin top well.

    Close up of sugar cookie dough in a glass bowl with a cookie dugh scoop in it.
    Top view of cookie dough scoops being added to a muffin top baking tray with a cookie scoop.

    Add a second smaller scoop of cookie dough on top (Small size #60), or just eyeball a smaller scoop.

    Use the bottom of a glass or a measuring cup that has been dipped in Granulated Sugar to press the cookies down flat.

    The edges will crackle and create a well in each cookie. The sugar on the bottom of the glass will help to prevent the glass from sticking to the cookie dough.

    Close up of a glass with sugar on the bottom hovering over a cookie dough ball in a muffin top baking tray.
    close up of a glass sitting on top of a flattened cookie sough ball in a muffin top pan.

    Bake the cookies in a preheated oven at 350 Degrees F for 8-10 minutes. The cookies will be set and lightly golden on the edges when they are done.

    Allow cookies to sit on the cookie sheet for a few minutes before moving them to a wire rack to cool completely before adding the topping.

    Top view of sugar cookies in a pie shape on a grid on a wire rack.

    Eggnog Filling

    In a medium bowl, combine the Vanilla Pudding and Eggnog. Whisk to combine.

    Carefully fold in the Whipped topping, being careful not to overmix.

    Top view of eggnog pie filling being whisked in a glass bow.

    Spoon the eggnog filling into each pie-shaped cookie and spread it to make it even. Alternatively, you can put the pie filling into a piping bag (or into a Ziploc bag and snip the corner off to make a small opening) and pipe it onto the top of the cookies, as I have done below.

    Close up of eggnog pie filling being piped onto a sugar cookie with a piping bag.

    Finally, garnish the top with additional whipped cream and a dusting of ground nutmeg for a festive finish!

    Close up of eggnog pie cookies on a plate with a glass of milk in the background.
    What are the ingredients for eggnog?

    Eggnog is traditionally associated with Christmas. It's a drink made with raw Egg Yolks, Heavy Cream, Vanilla, warm Spices, Whiskey, or Rum to make it alcoholic. A child-friendly eggnog recipe will be made with Rum Extract to give the flavor of authentic eggnog without the alcohol. It can be served hot or chilled, depending on personal preference.

    What's the difference between homemade eggnog and store-bought?

    A carton of eggnog that you buy from the grocery store will contain varying amounts of sugar, depending on the brand.

    How should I store eggnog pie sugar cookies?

    Store cooled Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies in a single layer in an airtight container and in the refrigerator for up to 7 days. Cookies are best if enjoyed within 2-3 days.

    Can I freeze eggnog pie sugar cookies?

    These eggnog pie cookies can be made ahead of time and frozen for a quick and easy Christmas dessert.
    Store the cookies by adding pieces of parchment paper between each cookie (or wrapping each cookie in plastic wrap) to keep them from sticking together. Freeze them both for up to 3 months.
    Simply defrost thoroughly before assembling your cookies!

    Close up of an eggnog pie sugar cookie with a bite taken out of it, on top of two other cookies on a white plate.

    Substitutions & Variations

    • Use homemade eggnog instead of store-bought eggnog if you can. This way you can control the sweetness and the amounts of spices used. If you can't get a hold of actual eggnog, you can use some milk and eggnog extract as a substitute.
    • For a stronger eggnog flavor, add a bit more eggnog to the frosting or add some eggnog extract to the cookies.
    • Alternatively, for a milder eggnog flavor, use less eggnog in the frosting. You could use a Vanilla Frosting and add cinnamon or ginger to it to make it more festive.
    • Add a dollop of my Eggnog Frosting to the top of the eggnog filling to decorate.
    • Add some crushed macadamia nuts, almonds, or chopped pecans into the dough or crumble them on top.
    • Serve these eggnog cookies with a cold glass of milk, a cold glass of eggnog, or a cup of hot eggnog.
    Top view of a lot of eggnog pie cookies on a pile on a plate, single on a plate, and on a wire rack.

    Pro Tips

    What makes a good cookie? Does it have a soft center, crispy edges, and chewy? Each of these makes a great quality cookie. To make perfect cookies every time here are some pro tips.

    To find out more, check out my Pro Tips Guide for making the best cookies!

    Weighing Ingredients.

    Baking is a science and adding too much or too little of any of the ingredients will alter the recipe. Weighing and measuring dry ingredients properly makes a world of difference, so investing in a kitchen scale is ideal. When a kitchen scale is not available make sure to stir and lift ingredients before scooping them into a measuring cup.

    VolumeOuncesGrams
    All Purpose Flour1 Cup4½ Ounces120 Grams
    Bread Flour1 Cup4½ Ounces120 Grams
    Granulated Sugar1 Cup7 Ounces200 Grams
    Brown Sugar1 Cup7½ Ounces213 Grams
    Confectionary Sugar1 Cup4 Ounces113 Grams

    Cookie Scoop.

    Using a cookie scoop keeps each ball of cookie dough the same size which is essential for baking. I have used a medium cookie scoop in these photos.

    Cookie Sheets.

    Your cookie sheet can usually be ungreased. I like to use Parchment Paper liners or a Silicone Mat for easy cleanup. For making the muffin top, use a muffin top pan to create these mini pie-shaped cookies.

    Baking Time.

    Every oven heats a little differently. I recommend doing a test batch of 1-3 cookies to test the baking time for a perfectly baked cookie before baking the remaining dough.

    Cookies.

    Cookies are perfectly baked when edges are set and centers are no longer glossy.

    Cooling Rack.

    Allow cookies to cool on the baking sheet for a minute or two before moving them to a cooling rack to cool completely.

    • Kitchen Scale. I use this for accuracy in measuring and it's a life saver when it comes to consistent baking
    • Wire Rack for cooling cookies. I like to have at least 2 cooling racks
    • Mixing Bowls. A Large Mixing Bowl for mixing ingredients and small and medium mixing bowls for other ingredients
    • Cookie Sheet. Most recipes will take 2 batches to bake. It's great to have multiple baking sheets available
    • Parchment Paper or Silicone Baking Mat. Line Cookie Sheet with parchment paper for easy clean up and to prevent sticking.
    • Cookie Scoop. A small #60 Cookie Scoop or a Medium Cookie Scoop #50 are great choices for uniform drops of cookie dough.
    • Storage Container. An Airtight Container to store cookies or ZipLoc Bags work great too.
    • Additional supplies. Measuring Cups and Measuring Spoons along with silicone spatula are all helpful
    Close up of an eggnog pie sugar cookie with a bite taken out of it.

    Have you tried these Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies?

    Let me know what you thought of this recipe! Tag @bestcookierecipes on social media so I can see how great your cookies turned out! I would also love to read your comments below to let me know what you thought of these cute cookies. It really does help!

    More Christmas Cookies You Will Love

    • Candy Cane Blossoms
    • Classic Sugar Cookies
    • Rudolf the Reindeer Cookies
    • Salted Caramel Cookies
    • Christmas Tree Blossom Cookies
    • Christmas Chocolate Dipped Butter Cookies
    • Traditional Soft Molasses Cookies
    • Air Fryer Festive Sugar Cookies
    • Grinch Sugar Cookies
    Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe Rate this Recipe

    Eggnog Sugar Cookie Pies

    These Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies will bring you so much festive cheer! Made with warmly spiced eggnog, every bite is delicious, and you won't be able to stop at just one!
    Prep Time15 minutes mins
    Cook Time9 minutes mins
    Total Time23 minutes mins
    Prevent your screen from going dark
    Servings: 15

    Ingredients

    Cookies

    • ½ cup Butter softened
    • ½ cup Granulated Sugar 100g
    • 1 Egg large
    • ½ teaspoon Vanilla Extract
    • ¼ cup Vegetable Oil
    • ½ cup Powdered Sugar 65g
    • 2 cups All Purpose Flour 240g
    • ½ teaspoon Baking Soda
    • ½ teaspoon Cream of Tartar

    Eggnog Filling

    • 1 package Vanilla Pudding 3.4 ounce box
    • 1 ¼ cup Eggnog
    • 4 ounces Cool Whip Topping
    • ½ teaspoon Nutmeg Garnish optional

    Instructions

    Cookies

    • Pre-heat Oven to 350 F Degrees.
    • In a large mixing bowl, or using a stand mixer on medium speed, cream together softened Butter and Granulated Sugar until light and fluffy.
    • Add Egg and Vanilla Extract to the butter mixture and continue to mix together.
    • Drizzle Vegetable Oil into the butter mixture and add the Powdered Sugar. Scrape the sides of the bowl as needed to include all ingredients. Cream until fully combined and fluffy.
    • Combine Flour, Baking Soda, and Cream of Tarter. Combine with butter mixture - do not overmix.
    • Using a Medium #50 Cookie Scoop place one scoop of cookie dough in each muffin top well. Add a second smaller scoop of cookie dough on top (Small size #60), or just eyeball a smaller scoop.
    • Using the bottom of a glass or a measuring cup that has been dipped in Granulated Sugar, press the cookies down flat. The edges will crackle and create a well in each cookie. The sugar on the bottom of the glass helps to prevent the glass from sticking.
    • Bake cookies in a preheated oven at 350 Degrees F for 8-10 minutes. Cookies will be set and lightly golden on the edges when they are done.
    • Allow cookies to sit on the cookie sheet for a few minutes before moving them to a wire rack to cool completely before adding the topping.

    Eggnog Filling

    • In a medium bowl combine the Vanilla Pudding and Eggnog. Whisk to combine.
    • Carefully fold in the Whipped topping.
    • Spoon the eggnog filling into each pie-shaped cookie.
    • Garnish with additional whipped topping and a dusting of ground nutmeg (optional).

    Notes

    Perfect Pie Crust Cookies:
    • Bake these cookies using a Muffin Top Pan for best results.
    • The cookie dough can also be placed on a baking sheet and pressed flat with the bottom of a glass before baking if you don't have a muffin top pan.
    • Place the eggnog filling on top just before serving for the best results.
    Storage:
    • Storage: Store cooled Eggnog Pie Sugar Cookies in an airtight container and in the refrigerator for up to 7 days. Cookies are best if enjoyed within 2-3 days.
    • Freezing: Freeze the sugar cookie bases and eggnog filling separately. Freeze the eggnog pie filling in a freezer-safe container, or a freezer Ziploc bag, making it as flat as possible for easy defrosting. Store the cookies in a similar way, adding pieces of parchment paper between each cookie (or wrapping each cookie in plastic wrap) to keep them from sticking together. Freeze them both for up to 3 months. Simply defrost thoroughly before assembling your cookies!
    Tried this recipe?Mention @bestcookierecipes or tag #bestcookierecipes!
    Show Nutrition Information Hide Nutrition Information
    Calories: 204kcal | Carbohydrates: 33g | Protein: 4g | Fat: 6g | Saturated Fat: 2g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 2g | Monounsaturated Fat: 1g | Trans Fat: 0.04g | Cholesterol: 24mg | Sodium: 116mg | Potassium: 85mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 18g | Vitamin A: 65IU | Vitamin C: 0.3mg | Calcium: 54mg | Iron: 1mg

    Nutrition Disclaimer

    All nutrition values are approximate and calculated by a plugin and are provided as a courtesy. Adding or subtracting ingredients will change the nutritional value.

    Share
    Pin
    Post
    Share
    « Easy Christmas Ornament Cookies Recipe (Chocolate Sandwich)
    Chewy Chocolate Peppermint Crinkle Cookies Recipe »

    Reader Interactions

    Submit a Comment Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    Devour Dinner Head Shot

    Making YOUR Day More Delicious!

    Find the Joy in baking and making memories with delicious cookie recipes.  Hi!  I'm Rebecca and I hope you will explore this site and find some of the BEST Cookie Recipes you've ever tried, all in one place!

    More about me →

    Latest

    • Close up image of a hand holding a Peach Pie Bar.
      Peach Pie Bars
    • Fig Jam Cookies
      Fig Jam Cookies
    • Peanut Butter Stuffed Chocolate Cookies
      Peanut Butter Stuffed Chocolate Cookies
    • Subway Chocolate Chip Cookies Footlong
      Subway Footlong Cookie Copycat Recipe

    Popular Categories

    • Classic Cookies
    • Drop Cookies
    • Cake Mix Cookies
    • No Bake Cookies

    Visit Our Sister Site!

    Devour Dinner Head Shot

    Making YOUR Day More Delicious!

    Find the Joy in baking and making memories with delicious cookie recipes.  Hi!  I'm Rebecca and I hope you will explore this site and find some of the BEST Cookie Recipes you've ever tried, all in one place!

    More about me →

    Latest

    • Strawberry White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
      Strawberry Macadamia Nut Cookies with White Chocolate Chips
    • Pencil Cookies made with Wafer Sugar cookies
      Pencil Wafer Cookies
    • Chocolate Chip Walnut cookies
      Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies
    • Edible Snickerdoodle Cookie Dough
      Edible Snickerdoodle Cookie Dough

    Popular Categories

    • Classic Cookies
    • Drop Cookies
    • Cake Mix Cookies
    • No Bake Cookies

    Visit Our Sister Site!

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclosure Policy
    • Contact

    Connect

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

    Join My FREE Newsletter

    Success! You have signed up for our email list.

    Copyright © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Devour Dinner